|
Some Common Myths Thought to be True - Myth 145
Myth 145: The Pioneers Circled their Wagons to Stave Off Indian Attacks
On the Oregon Trail and other trails, pioneers circled their wagons to protect
the party against weather and theft! Circling the wagons was an invention of
Hollywood filmmakers who liked the way it looked on film.
At night, wagon trains were often formed into a circle or square for shelter
from wind or weather, and to corral the emigrants' animals in the center to
prevent them from running away or being stolen by Native Americans. While
Indians might attempt to raid horses under cover of darkness, they rarely
attacked a train. Contrary to popular belief, wagons were seldom circled
defensively
|
|
Veteran Western historians the Michnos, are out to set the record straight on
the "did they or didn't they?" question regarding Indian attacks on pioneer
wagon trains. The prevailing conventional wisdom is that, despite the ubiquity
of wagon train attacks in popular culture such as Hollywood film portrayals,
these attacks were rare.
As the Michnos prove in Circle the Wagons! Attacks on Wagon Trains in History
and Hollywood, conventional wisdom is not only wrong, it's "plainly, simply,
irrevocably wrong." They decry as "whitewashing" frontier history the recent
disturbing trend of western historians to focus almost exclusively on white
atrocities while simultaneously ignoring Indian depredations - presenting
Indians merely as hapless "victims" of white aggression.
The Michnos also link the real-life wagon train attacks in each chapter to
Hollywood films that portray either the actual historical event or an attack
that exhibits similar aspects to those depicted in the film.
|